%PDF-1.3
%
1 0 obj
<>
stream
Brian WalkerHuman natures and the resilience of social-ecological systems: a comment on the Erhlichs' paper2010-11-11T18:53:54Zapplication/pdf
endstream
endobj
2 0 obj
<>
endobj
3 0 obj
<>
endobj
4 0 obj
<>
endobj
5 0 obj
<>
endobj
6 0 obj
<>
endobj
7 0 obj
<>
endobj
8 0 obj
<>
endobj
9 0 obj
<>
endobj
10 0 obj
<>
endobj
11 0 obj
<>
endobj
12 0 obj
<>
endobj
13 0 obj
<>
endobj
14 0 obj
<>
endobj
15 0 obj
<>
endobj
16 0 obj
<>/ExtGState<>>>
endobj
17 0 obj
<>
stream
q
0.2 i
0 663 449 -664 re
0 663 m
W n
0.03 663.03 442.02 -663 re
W n
BT
/F2 1 Tf
9.5 0 0 9.5 65.6929 581.8405 Tm
0 0 0 1 k
/GS1 gs
-0.0001 Tc
0.2604 Tw
(application of effective IRM might be impeded by informational con-)Tj
0 -1.1579 TD
-0.0002 Tc
0.2973 Tw
[(straints. Thus failure to effectively monitor whether the pre-specied)]TJ
T*
-0.0001 Tc
0.1431 Tw
(proportion of land is planted with )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
16.1842 0 TD
-0.0004 Tc
0 Tw
(Bt)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.3367 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.1431 Tw
(crops creates a situation of moral)Tj
-17.5209 -1.1579 TD
0.1063 Tw
(hazard with hidden actions. Under moral hazard the proportion of land)Tj
T*
-0.0002 Tc
0.0102 Tw
(maintained for non-)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
8.8795 0 TD
-0.0004 Tc
0 Tw
(Bt)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.2038 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.0102 Tw
(\(conventional\) crops will fall short of what the IRM)Tj
-10.0833 -1.1579 TD
-0.0002 Tc
0.1663 Tw
[(rule species. A strong institutional framework is therefore required in)]TJ
T*
-0.0001 Tc
0.0249 Tw
(order to secure the effective application of the IRM.)Tj
1 -1.1579 TD
0.0948 Tw
[(Although such an institutional framework might be expected either to)]TJ
-1 -1.1579 TD
0.1015 Tw
(exist or to be relatively easily created in developed countries, this might)Tj
T*
0.0729 Tw
(not be the case in developing countries where a large proportion of agri-)Tj
T*
0.4021 Tw
[(culture is in the hands of small-scale farmers. The combination of)]TJ
T*
-0.0002 Tc
0.3169 Tw
(small-holder farming, incentives for short-run benets from )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
28.9026 0 TD
-0.0004 Tc
0 Tw
(Bt)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.5104 0 TD
-0.0002 Tc
(crops)Tj
-30.413 -1.1579 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.0084 Tw
[(under conditions of pressure to increase food supply, and structural prob-)]TJ
T*
0.4384 Tw
(lems related to the creation of regulatory institutions could create)Tj
T*
0.0767 Tw
[(situations of unregulated use of )]TJ
/F1 1 Tf
14.631 0 TD
-0.0004 Tc
0 Tw
(Bt)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.2703 0 TD
-0.0002 Tc
0.0768 Tw
(technology. Therefore, unless )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
13.4875 0 TD
-0.0004 Tc
0 Tw
(Bt)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.2703 0 TD
-0.0002 Tc
(tech-)Tj
-30.6591 -1.1579 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.1915 Tw
(nology is introduced along with an effective regulatory framework, its)Tj
T*
0.1069 Tw
(potential productivity advantages might be mitigated relatively faster in)Tj
T*
0.1057 Tw
[(cases where they are needed more and could produce the highest incre-)]TJ
T*
0.0249 Tw
(mental benets.)Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0 -2.3158 TD
0 Tw
(References)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
8.5 0 0 8.5 65.6929 351.8405 Tm
0.0465 Tw
(Birch, A., I. Geoghenana, M. Majerus, J. McNicol, C. Hackett, A. Gatehouse, and J.)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
0.1494 Tw
(Gatehouse \(1999\), Tri-trophic interactions involving pest aphids, predatory 2-)Tj
T*
0.193 Tw
(spot ladybirds and transgenic potatoes expressing snowdrop lectin for aphid)Tj
T*
-0.0002 Tc
0 Tw
(resistance, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
5.1451 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.025 Tw
(Molecular Breeding)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
8.0143 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, )Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.525 0 TD
(5)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
0.5 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(\(1\): 75)-55()-55(83.)]TJ
-15.1844 -1.1765 TD
0.2166 Tw
(Brock, W.A. and A. Xepapadeas \(2000\), Productivity enhancing genetic engin-)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
-0.0002 Tc
0.2125 Tw
[(eering: externalities and management rules, mimeo, The Resilience Network)]TJ
T*
-0.0001 Tc
0.025 Tw
[(Theory Group, http:/)249.9(/)55.1(www.soc.uoc.gr)110(/)55.1(xepapadeas)110(/Papers)110(/)55.1(indexpapers.html)]TJ
-1 -1.1765 TD
0.0871 Tw
(Ehrlich, P. and A. Ehrlich \(2001\), Population, development, and human natures,)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
1 -1.1765 TD
0.025 Tw
(Environment and Development Economics)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
17.3592 0 TD
(, this volume.)Tj
-18.3592 -1.1765 TD
0.3209 Tw
(EPA \(2000\), EPA advisors assess risks, benets of Bt crops, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
29.8553 0 TD
0 Tw
(http://www.cast-)Tj
-28.8553 -1.1765 TD
(science.org/biotechnology)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
-1 -1.1765 TD
0.1285 Tw
(Feldman, J. \(1997\), Development of strategies to prevent Colorado potato beetle)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
0.7169 Tw
(resistance to newleaf potatoes: an industry rst, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
26.6224 0 TD
0 Tw
(http://www.ipmworld.)Tj
-26.6224 -1.1765 TD
(umn.edu/chapters/feldman.htm)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
-1 -1.1765 TD
0.1093 Tw
(Hilbeck, W. M. Baumgartner, P. Fried, and F. Bigler \(1998\), Effects of transgenic)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
-0.0002 Tc
-0.0306 Tw
[(bacillus thuringiensis corn-fed prey on mortality and development time of imma-)]TJ
T*
-0.0001 Tc
0.025 Tw
(ture chrysoperla carnea, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
11.2654 0 TD
(Environmental Entomology)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
11.2721 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(, )Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.525 0 TD
(27)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1 0 TD
0.025 Tw
[(, 480)-54.9()-54.9(487.)]TJ
-25.0625 -1.1765 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.0262 Tw
(Hurley, T., B. Babcock, and R. Hellmich \(1997\), Biotechnology and pest resistance:)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
0.0048 Tw
(an economic assessment of refuges, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
16.187 0 TD
(CARD, Iowa State University)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
12.2338 0 TD
(, Working Paper)Tj
-28.4208 -1.1765 TD
0.0251 Tw
(97-WP 183.)Tj
-1 -1.1765 TD
0.1558 Tw
(Hurley, T., S. Secchi, B. Babcock, and R. Hellmich \(1999\), Managing the risk of)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
0.0799 Tw
(European corn borer resistance to transgenic corn: an assessment of refuge rec-)Tj
T*
0 Tw
(ommendations, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
7.454 0 TD
0.025 Tw
(CARD, Iowa State University)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
12.2942 0 TD
(, Staff Report 99 SR 88.)Tj
-20.7482 -1.1765 TD
0.073 Tw
(James, G. \(1999\), Global status of commercialized transgenic crops, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
30.6769 0 TD
(ISSA Brief 12)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
5.7568 0 TD
0 Tc
0 Tw
(,)Tj
-35.4337 -1.1765 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.025 Tw
(Ithaca NY, ISAAA.)Tj
-1 -1.1765 TD
1.0434 Tw
(Interacademies.net \(2001\), Transgenic plants and world agriculture,)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
0 Tw
[(http:/)249.9(/)55.1(www.nap.edu.html)55.1(/)55.1(transgenic)]TJ
-1 -1.1765 TD
0.0177 Tw
(Liu, Y-B., B. Tabashnik, T. Dennehy, A. Patin, and A. Bartlett \(1999\), Development)Tj
1 -1.1765 TD
0.025 Tw
(time and resistance to Bt crops, )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
14.4088 0 TD
-0.0002 Tc
0 Tw
(Nature)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
2.8882 0 TD
0 Tc
(, )Tj
/F3 1 Tf
0.525 0 TD
(400)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
1.5 0 TD
0.025 Tw
(: 519.)Tj
-20.322 -1.1765 TD
-0.0001 Tc
-0.0362 Tw
(Mellon, M. and J. Rissler \(1998\), )Tj
/F1 1 Tf
14.024 0 TD
(Now or Never, Serious New Plans to save a Natural Pest)Tj
-13.024 -1.1765 TD
0 Tw
(Control)Tj
/F2 1 Tf
3.1101 0 TD
0.025 Tw
(, Cambridge, MA: Union of Concerted Scientists.)Tj
9.5 0 0 9.5 65.6929 605.9619 Tm
0 Tc
0 Tw
(190)Tj
/F1 1 Tf
2.5 0 TD
-0.0001 Tc
0.025 Tw
(Policy Forum)Tj
ET
Q
endstream
endobj
18 0 obj
<>
stream
8;Z\7>7uQB#g?lXo)<:\3c-b.n6!I?Va%?5Bq:-n$\9_RK3G@9g:A=),[V\GMlP
Cnt,JZ1%S'%ID5AmjD89ft-^'C90ubS"6YKc:jEGOh%lR]=UVR/HFKLYdNZ20KJ-k:Tl@c+l;)rD_/(Ibj?5a22PkYaZ53k7;T['5q]r9Y1;i.jCSIl
)\%/7n/M+]aCJ=^g\3Wen\_q4@P/mCGO*q37^9W9p>%%'ljD!IDDc
endstream
endobj
19 0 obj
[/Indexed/DeviceRGB 255 20 0 R]
endobj
20 0 obj
<>
stream
J,g]g+e/h_!_gCtO=0f)$P%cIi8Zdfc5&3j_8$7g.@L`YKUJNGBP\poR=_;Dl'P(T
(7Boo^^S:71(MN]ZQX/+Cbu.lK"p74pe1T%s.DY%&\1TdJhr54.M9au6>79n6`Q:4
PbLSZTLEE(8E@'*1mg_*eTnN*;*'V3+gm-EEetX%;Bo$ur2ss*N`.-!.kG_q6GDD'
dKoL!8Ka#EV,@V!\j8ZFbp6EE<9cn=N6j0nf;(&;QU6bUD')c@\
9-d\DA=cZ0Q>gIM$$;cd2O@&a;X,Nn_aP(]I1aRc(K1^ue>
gF/(+GaKo$qneLWDrQ#;5\S(\$q'4Q,85`-8;S(=Z"WSBOV*FM)4,?B],R
endstream
endobj
21 0 obj
<>
endobj
22 0 obj
<>
endobj
23 0 obj
<>
endobj
24 0 obj
<>
endobj
25 0 obj
<>
endobj
26 0 obj
<>
stream
HtiPSYKxIQx>;<-P[%
le&d#"BB046.D6Q.nq驱۪N1/]azV9qZyJ%,$76n`-@ry7N%1W5iRt{8mv``\`va&rVpܕ:8$+ωByrڿ|p) 7ɌNNҍl0S}0gi-Zm]%Χ "n[K 2|8!7$B9c9b~p&kŻrC/ڑvyEira:͉9o9,cӵ]Ul=5:>NnK贶wŷE+DG݄\yNH5ȟA,W(Q"+zTBaP_x:ɫQΨt \T<)N!
\ݤj+D>|f2u]d^]K$ W~R0l!Ü^*wײ^=a{s1?.J.EebtMX+cE_mψ)BmuwVKoSa{2K@!3
AlYT!]-sbqe'=2wO:=D妄˓"up\v}woXB"ߧ(o8n:.#_{{+.?JV|c%,ZƝoA n< MP'y$<؉fҫ
&b8^K^PDM܂D=- 0f^YocUW1֒"bTE*VsХ0aҘ7EI?GhyhnP#{ڣY鯺vSHɪY/mP#WC}ǥ Xva y_YQB``&laѬ.WnQf'"R#>,8p`֫:u|9c2__7uV-jaApp*u&'g)Du|gsmZGt
&BF}8t J<
kyDgٟ*d3AWהzM
LХv˶>v>]%I|v]ۓN%rG!7l:.'rCz]1 dhlookޣ hvl*o.f>{n`{|9hmx]J~ڳ{1"Vp@rdScs T/a
J5X˕r6oߺV5? e$W$g! nS^7<|R5g*7h7EZ
pk({dV=6h[7C\["DS݈w4Ic찋{o:cwZi9F,AնZ^ntNhMfiKR%F)+k/ +2fkt+ POdóGlE?w癧Ǹo7D&RB2T24NP
S).ˣJ**dQQFZ
|7F;(\}TQF\ t*